Accruals vs Cash Accounting
Wondering whether to prepare your financial statements under the Cash Accounting method or Accruals Accounting method is not a common question, and the reason for that is that many business owners don’t know there is a choice, and often don’t know the difference.
Put simply;
- Cash Accounting is the method of recording transactions when they have a cash impact.
For example, recording a sale when the cash is received in your bank from the customer, or recording a purchase of goods or services when the cash is paid out of your bank to the supplier.
- Accruals Accounting is the method of recording transactions when they should have happened, regardless of whether they have yet had an impact on cash.
For example, recording a sale when invoiced to the customer, not waiting for the cash to be received, and recording a cost to the business when the commitment to pay has been identified, ie. when the bill is received, or when the work took place even if the bill hasn’t yet been received.
There’s pros and cons for both, both have a valid place, and there will be a reason why you choose one over the other. But it needs to be decided based on the needs of the business, the structure of the business, and/or the needs of the business owner and how they want to represent their management accounts to successfully run their business.
If you read Mike Michalowicz book Profit First, you’ll see he’s a big advocate of the Cash Accounting method, and gives very good reasons as to why he believes that. And there is some logic in his argument, particularly with small businesses or new businesses, as it is an explicit way of seeing the real results of how you’re trading within your business.
I would argue that as you scale up and your business becomes more complex, Accruals Accounting gives a more realistic view, and allows you to make decisions in a more long-term and strategic manner.
But, there’s not necessarily a right or wrong, just a right or wrong for your business at this point in time, so advice is the thing you need!
Many new and small business owners find Accruals Accounting too complicated to administer, and don’t have the resources yet to employ a bookkeeper to help on a daily basis. Cash Accounting is also useful when cash is very restricted, or in a financial crisis within your business.
Remember the age old saying “turnover is vanity, profit is sanity, but cash is king” … well, it might be old but it will always be true.
High turnover doesn’t necessarily mean high profits, and profits don’t necessarily translate into cash.
You can run a business with zero profits, but you cannot run a business with zero cash.
Hopefully this has helped, but if it’s only added to your confusion then get in touch to help establish what’s right for you and your business at this point in time.
