Is it okay to promise a reward based on targets, and then not delivering on that promise when conditions are met?
Surely the answer to the title question has to be a resounding NO!
I’ve always been of the opinion that you should only offer a reward for effort against something that is entirely at the mercy of the receiver.
Say you give your manager a budget, and they are to be rewarded by staying within the budget boundaries, then you cannot overrule how they choose to spend it, or not spend it, by making decisions on their behalf.
Giving the promise of a reward should be within the control of the person promised.
Likewise, if you set targets, they must be achievable. It would be unfair targeting your Office Administrator with reducing the time it takes to stack shelves, as if they are not the person that stacks the shelves then this isn’t within their control to achieve it.
Or promising a bonus to your production team if they achieve £1m sales this year, if the sales team only bring £800K of work in to the business, as the potential to achieve isn’t possible.
Ultimately it’s very demotivating to set non achievable targets, and it could backfire in the long run, as your team realise there is little point even trying. And eventually you may lose good employees as they form a distrust in what you say.
Finally, if the target is achieved then ensure you go ahead and give the reward. A fruitless promise won’t serve you or your business well.
So before making the promise of a reward for efforts, ensure the rewards are there to be given, and be sure that you will go through with actually delivering on your promise at the end of the day. Otherwise you may find that your actions have resulted in a situation opposing to the one you were trying to create!
