To incorporate or not? That is the question.

When you set up in business, is it better to start as a self-employed owner, or to register the business as a Limited company?

It’s a common question, and it would be great if there were a standard answer for all situations.  But unfortunately there isn’t a standard conclusion to draw, there are instead a whole host of circumstances to consider and consequences to consider.

And here are a selection of those considerations:

Legal Status

As a sole trader you are your business, but if you incorporate your business then that becomes a separate legal entity.  Being incorporated gives the shareholders limited liability. 

Fiduciary Duties

Incorporating a business and becoming a Director of that business imposes statutory fiduciary duties upon that Director. This is because, as a Director, you are a person of trust and confidence, and there is an expectation that you will act in the best interests of the company.

Companies House

Once a business is incorporated there is a duty to file statutory Financial Statements, which are available for public view, as well as an annual return (Confirmation Statement) and any changes to the company, for example Shareholders and Directors.

HMRC

However you trade in business you will have to inform HMRC, as both sole traders and Shareholders of incorporated companies have an obligation to file an annual Self-Assessment Tax Return. The specific details within your tax return may vary, but the need to complete one will potentially be there for both.

Taxes

As a sole trader you will pay taxes on your income (and business profits) under the Income Tax rules, but as an employee of an incorporated company you will you pay personal tax under Income Tax rules on your salary and dividends, but the business will pay Corporation Tax based on company profits.

Salary vs Dividends

As a Shareholder of an incorporated company you may be paid via Dividends instead of Salary (or a combination of both), which can give some personal tax savings.

Filing Duties

As a sole trader you do not have to prepare statutory financial statements for your business, whereas your incorporated business would have to, and they have to be filed with Companies House.  But the obligation to file may be the only difference, the need to prepare accurate and timely financial statements will still exist in order to help you as a business owner.

Additional Costs

Incorporating your company will bring some additional costs, i.e. Companies House registration fee, and perhaps additional accountancy fees for Statutory Financial Statements preparation and filing.  And this might be an additional reason to only incorporate once your business gets to a size that justifies those costs.  But if you know that’s where you are heading in the longer term anyway, then it might be worthwhile incorporating immediately, simply to claim the name you want (as in the UK two incorporated companies cannot have identical names).

Impression

Being a Ltd Company tends to give the impression that there is more than just you, and that you are a fairly sizeable business.  To a certain extent that might be true, as typically businesses tend to incorporate when they start to scale or employ people, so that isn’t always a misconception.  But if you want to create the impression you are bigger than the reality, then registering your company could create that impression for you.

Conversely, if you are small, and you are essentially selling yourself and your very specific personal skills, then sometimes not being incorporated may help you to connect with your target market.  A client feeling that they might end up being looked after by other people in the business instead of you, might be off-putting for them.

It’s similar to deciding whether to market yourself as “I” or “we”.  How big or small do you want your audience to feel that you are.  Being big might benefit your clients who need a continuation of service, being small and niche might help where it is a very personal service that only you would deliver anyway.

In Conclusion, the answer to the question “Should I incorporate my business or not?” will be a combination of personal choice, marketing considerations, costs and tax implications. Not easy perhaps?

But there is an easier answer … get in touch with all the relevant professionals (be that your Accountant, Financial Adviser, etc) and ask them for all of the considerations for each.  Write a list of pro’s and con’s, and I can almost guarantee that one or two will stand out and give you the answer that you need, dependent on your business.

So there may not be an easy answer and one-size-fits-all, but there will be an answer that’s right for you!